Executive Context

The Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) has released its pre-budget analysis identifying seven pressing fiscal and policy challenges that will shape Canada's Budget 2025 deliberations. This briefing comes as Canada faces mounting economic pressures, international commitments, and domestic policy uncertainties.

---

Key Issues Identified

1. Housing Crisis Intensifies

• Canada needs 3.5 million additional housing units by 2030 to restore affordability to 2003-2004 levels
• Current construction pace falls significantly short of targets
• Government housing initiatives face implementation and funding sustainability questions
• Implication: Without acceleration, housing affordability will continue deteriorating for middle-class Canadians

2. Carbon Pricing Policy Uncertainty

• Federal carbon pricing framework faces legal and political challenges
• Provincial opt-outs and court cases create revenue uncertainty for federal budgeting
• Rebate programs depend on carbon pricing revenues that may be disrupted
• Impact: Budget 2025 must address potential $billions in revenue volatility

3. Defence Spending Shortfall

• Canada committed to spending 2% of GDP on defence under NATO obligations
• Current defence spending: approximately 1.4% of GDP
• Gap represents roughly $20+ billion annually in additional spending required
• Timeline pressure: Allies expecting concrete plans in Budget 2025

4. Healthcare System Strain

• Aging population driving exponential healthcare cost growth
• Federal-provincial health transfers under negotiation
• Long-term care and mental health services facing critical capacity issues
• Financial exposure: Healthcare represents Canada's largest and fastest-growing budget item

5. Fiscal Anchor Credibility

• Government's debt-to-GDP ratio targets facing credibility questions
• Economic slowdown threatens revenue projections
• Rising interest rates increase debt servicing costs substantially
• Risk: Credit rating agencies monitoring fiscal discipline closely

6. Employment Insurance Reform Pressure

• EI system faces structural modernization needs for gig economy
• Premium rate sustainability questioned with changing work patterns
• Regional disparities in program access require addressing
• Challenge: Balancing worker protection with fiscal sustainability

7. Infrastructure Investment Backlog

• Municipal infrastructure facing $141+ billion repair deficit
• Climate adaptation investments needed for resilience
• Public transit systems require ongoing federal support
• Funding gap: Current federal commitments insufficient for identified needs

---

Critical Data Points

Issue	Financial Magnitude	Timeline
Housing shortfall	3.5M units needed	By 2030
Defence spending gap	~$20B annually	Immediate
Infrastructure deficit	$141B+ backlog	Ongoing
Healthcare cost growth	6-7% annually	Accelerating
Debt servicing costs	Rising with rates	2024-2026

---

Key Takeaways

1. Budget 2025 Faces Unprecedented Fiscal Constraints

• Multiple competing priorities with limited fiscal room
• Deficit reduction goals conflict with spending pressures
• Trade-offs will be necessary across all policy domains

2. International Commitments Create Non-Negotiable Costs

• NATO defence spending targets cannot be indefinitely deferred
• Canada's international credibility depends on meeting obligations
• Defence gap represents single largest discretionary spending pressure

3. Housing Crisis Requires Transformational Investment

• Incremental measures insufficient to meet 3.5M unit target
• Federal-provincial coordination essential for success
• Budget 2025 must signal multi-year commitment with concrete funding

4. Carbon Policy Uncertainty Threatens Revenue Stability

• Budget planning complicated by legal/political challenges to carbon pricing
• Government must develop contingency scenarios for revenue loss
• Alternative revenue sources may be required to maintain programs

5. Healthcare and Demographic Pressures Are Structural

• Aging population creates permanent upward cost pressure
• Federal share of healthcare funding will face provincial demands for increases
• Long-term fiscal planning must account for healthcare cost trajectory

---

Implications for Canadians

Budget 2025 will be a defining moment for Canada's fiscal policy direction. Parliamentarians face genuine trade-offs between:

• Maintaining social programs vs. deficit reduction
• Meeting international commitments vs. domestic priorities
• Short-term relief measures vs. long-term structural reforms

The PBO's analysis suggests no easy choices exist, and political consensus will be challenging given the scale of required fiscal adjustments.

Source: Parliamentary Budget Officer of Canada, "Budget 2025: Issues for Parliamentarians" (December 2024)